Skip to content

Beyond Innovation Theater

In Part 1, we focused on the concept of transformational innovation and covered many angles of the theme, such as people-centricity, technology, and disruption. In Part 2, we asked, how might design thinking play into this scenario? Here in Part 3, we look beyond technology, and ask how might creating the right culture play into the process? Then, at its foundation, how might the process itself make transformational innovation go?

All Things Innovation would like to thank the participants: Leslie Shannon, Head of Trend & Innovation Scouting, Nokia; Milan Ivosevic, VP R&D, CooperSurgical; Prapti Jha, T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Harvard University; Sudha Ranganathan, Director Marketing & Talent Solutions, LinkedIn; Harsh Wardhan, Innovation Program Lead, Google; Nevada Sanchez, Co-Founder & VP, Core Tech. Eng., Butterfly Network, Inc.; Oscar Barranco Liebana, Innovation Director, FIFA World Cup 2022; Angelina Carvajal, Strategy & Innovation Partner, Sr. Dir. (Optum Advisory), UnitedHealth Group; and Cherie Leonard, Director of NA Insights, Colgate-Palmolive.

Transforming the Theater

Sudha Ranganathan notes, “Earlier when we were discussing our pet peeves, this is before the recording started, you spoke about something that really resonated today. It was the term ‘innovation theater.’ And I feel like it touches upon what you’re getting at right now, which is, it’s easy to talk about how to generate great ideas. What’s really hard is embedding that into the DNA of an organization, and then creating commercialization out of it so that at least a few ideas see the light of day. I feel like that ‘innovation theater’ is such a brilliant phrase to encapsulate how hard process is.”

Cherie Leonard says, “What struck me about the innovation theater was the matrix. And they looked at the growth potential and then the– it was business model driven really. And I think even sometimes the most disruptive ideas, we fall back on the business models that we know. And they talked about, I think, how that turns into innovation theater, because you’re going through the process and you have the incubation and everything, but then what’s actually scaled is in line with an existing comfortable business model. So, you kill all the big disruptive ideas. And I feel like that’s such a tremendous risk.”

Can incentives play a role in moving beyond innovation theater at an organization? Ranganathan adds, “A lot of it boils down to something brought up earlier around incentives. If an organization is incentivized to reward things and measure them the conventional way using the original standard byline, then it’s really hard to reward any innovative ideas, because they’re not going to fulfill the same P&L requirements that a one-year out incremental idea we’ll deliver.”

Prapti Jha notes, “If I may, because we are talking about new terms and fun theater, so I’ll just add one more into the mix. Patrick Whitney, who’s a professor at Harvard, he has this term called ‘innovation suicide.’ I won’t go into all the 10 ways, but he says, ‘Innovation suicide, 10 ways organizations kill their own ideas.’ And one of the last one that he says, ‘Everyone wants innovation and transformation as long as it doesn’t require change.’ And that’s powerful, because I don’t want to change my process, I don’t want to change my culture mindset, but we want to be innovative.”

For Milan Ivosevic, the path to innovation is key. He says, “I’ll challenge you to find any single company on planet Earth, if you go and ask them, ‘Do you have any sort of innovation?’ ‘Oh yeah.’ Everybody, it’s so sexy and popular, you have to do something with innovation. But when you go from innovation, and if it doesn’t go all the way and it doesn’t become a product, then what’s the point?”

Leslie Shannon adds, “I recently heard a presentation from another company, another large Silicon Valley company, not mine, about their innovation culture. And one of the things they said that was key for success was making it part of the manager’s incentives for genuinely bringing innovative products to market. And they said that was it. Now, because it’s not my company, I don’t know if it’s actually working or not, but that to me actually sounds like a pretty good idea.”

Diving into Process

So can an organization at least strive tooperationalize their transformational innovation? What else can be done honestly at both large and small organizations where we can at least begin the process of operationalizing this true transformation, which we know needs to happen?

Harsh Wardhan says, “When I heard the term innovation theater, I thought you were talking about theatrics that people put around process to make a lot of money, which is a good business. Now let’s think about the process that is deployed in the companies, or organizations, or the lack thereof. Some people talk about white space ideation, brainstorming, ‘Let’s come together, let’s think about the next great idea over coffee and a lot of sugar.’ That’s the lack of process.”

Wardhan continues, “The other one is, ‘I know this process works. This is the design thinking. I’m going to be following it to a T and disrupt the industry.’ That doesn’t work either. The first one doesn’t work, because it’s a lot of white space thinking, a lot of ideas in the sky, the rubber doesn’t meet the road. This one, we get bogged down in analysis paralysis as we call it. We think too much about process, we cut everything down. It’s a mess. That rubber doesn’t meet the road there either. So, what do we need to do to operationalize transformational innovation is to enable our people to work with flexible processes. It is not only one way that you can do it. Yes, you can use this process, but be flexible to change it down the road.”

Flexibility could be a key process of transformational innovation, agrees Ivosevic. “You inspired me to think about the way I see this. We are talking about process. Process is almost kind of prescribed way of doing things. That somehow doesn’t fit with the free nature of free spirit innovations. On the other side, the extreme is having nothing. So, I believe that kind of concepts and frameworks that kind of provide general guide rails are kind of directing you but don’t go too far into process, because now you start prescribing the way to think about it.”

Wardhan adds, “I like to think about process as alphabets. Not all words are the same. We use processes, frameworks or methodologies. You use different alphabets to make words and sentences. That’s how you make process with frameworks and methodologies. I think that’s a good way to think about it.”

One factor about process, it’s important to break the silos as much as possible to enhance the collective intelligence of the venture.

Oscar Barranco Liebana makes his own observation about the process and the intelligence learned collectively: “One important thing that we learned from the interaction of so many different stakeholders is that each organization has their own agenda, their own processes, and their own way of thinking. So, what we learned is that if we can maximize the collective intelligence from different stakeholders, we were improving the intelligence for innovation. And that means that we are breaking the silos, we’re breaking the processes, and the collective intelligence of the ‘super mind,’ what we call different stakeholders from different perspectives. If you are, for example, addressing the different value dimensions, if you are involving the implementers of the solutions, and you have a very strong antagonist that they are creating friction and conflict, we are creating an environment where with this friction and interaction, you are improving and raising the intelligence for innovation. And, I think, this is something very important, because it doesn’t depend on one single organization. You are creating intelligence and distributed through many.”

Transformation, and its variety of processes, the panelists seem to agree, takes a lot of collaboration—and time.

Angelina Caravajal says, “I think we’re using innovation and transformation to mean the same thing, but in fact they’re very different. And so, not for me to define it, but let’s say transformation innovation, now that we are talking about it, let’s say we know what we mean by innovation, product, business model, service, experience, whatever. Once you have that, then you need to transform something. You may need to transform your own organization, your culture, build new revenue streams, create new connections, create new customers, new ways of working. That’s something very deliberate. And that takes time. As much as innovation, filling that innovation pipeline, bringing innovation to market takes time, transforming your organization, transforming the market to adopt your awesome innovation takes a lot of effort. Those are different concepts, right? And they require different skills that require a lot of collaboration, a lot of trust.”

Click here for the full All Things Innovation FEI Roundtable on transformational innovation.

Contributor

  • Seth Adler

    Seth Adler heads up All Things Insights & All Things Innovation. He has spent his career bringing people together around content. He has a dynamic background producing events, podcasts, video, and the written word.

 
 

Related Content

Bulletin board with post it notes. One in center says Make Things Happen.
innovation team

Managing Productive Innovation

Conservatively, I estimate that I’ve attended 20,000-plus meetings throughout my career. I’ll admit, many of them should have been replaced with email…

A blueprint with a pencil and ruler.
delivery effectiveness

Innovation Principles, 7/7

Once adequate competency, support, and size of a new team are secured, clear direction based on a purposeful vision, alignment with a winning game pla…

coin operated binoculars and open blue sky
artificial intelligence

The Road to FEI24: Analytics for Innovation

Anu Sundaram, Vice President, Business Analytics, Rue Gilt Groupe, is planning an interactive analytics session for FEI 2024, taking place this June….

A smiling little robot
robotics

The Road to FEI24: Brunch with the Bots

Samantha Johnson, Founder & CEO at Tatum Robotics, will take part in FEI 2024 in several ways, including participating in the keynote sessions, “Bru…

mountain climbers trekking
innovation-led growth

Discovering the Innovation-Led Growth Journey

Advances in artificial intelligence are powering AI-driven innovation. As machines become smarter and tech developments are rapidly progressing, there…

explorer in a cave
user experience

Applying AI to Anthropological Research

Agile research and methodologies are of primary importance to the innovation discipline, as they promote a more versatile, rapid, adaptive approach to…

gross profit margin

Innovation Principles, 5/7

Gross Profit Margin and Net Present Value are two primary profitability indicators for evaluating an intended entrepreneurial offering. Even if suffic…

agile innovation

Finding the Way to Business Transformation

The concept of business transformation can be defined with a broad range of meanings depending upon the business and the different stakeholders that p…

future of work

Gaining an Innovation Edge with Automation

With the focus on how artificial intelligence, as well as digital transformation efforts, can help streamline operations, it’s worth another look at…

innovation partnerships

Creating the Right Innovation Partnership

Corporations often face many challenges when it comes to developing innovation in a fast, evolving market. They can face barriers such as inertia, the…

innovation talent

Bringing Sales and Innovation Together

Just how can innovation and sales work together to find success? Too often, companies find themselves stuck in their respective departments and the si…

universal interactivity

Advancing Universal Interaction

Artificial intelligence, specifically generative AI, has the potential to be a great equalizing disruptive technology of our time. While we are still…

design thinking

Innovation Principles, 4/7

The front end of innovation is a distinctly iterative endeavor based on human-centered, design-thinking principles. It could be represented by a spira…

innovation mindset

Winning the Innovation Strategy Game

We know that having a creative mindset can fuel innovation, and that fostering a culture of innovation is also important to get the job done. Yet ther…

innovation culture

Taking Next Steps with Innovation Talent

As we head into the new year, taking the next steps with innovation talent remains an important question to explore. With the competitive landscape in…

innovation talent

PIE: Get Your Slice of Success

How can someone really stand out and succeed as a corporate innovator, get the most exciting projects, or secure a promotion? This is a question I enc…

disruptive innovation

Shaping the Future with Disruptive Technology

As we head into 2024, innovation of all types, most especially in technology, will continue to disrupt, transform and impact our lives, from the workp…

future of work

Keeping Your Innovation Career Resilient

With the rise of technology, such as AI, impacting workers and workplaces, it’s safe to say the future of work is evolving—in innovation and in ma…

design thinking

Innovation Principles, 3/7

The main premise behind an integrated end-to-end continuum of innovation and new product development is that a holistic understanding of sequential de…

external innovation

Embracing Open Innovation

Open innovation is a growing tactic for today’s globalized enterprises. Rather than focusing just on closed loop systems and internal sources, such…

Generation Z

Shaping the Next Generation of Innovation

Generation Z is in a unique position as they are often viewed as one of the first to be shaped and influenced by technology such as the Internet, soci…

design thinking

Innovation Principles, 2/7

Successful innovation endeavors are built on creative tension between key enabling entrepreneurial trade-offs associated with four must-have constitue…

risk management

Unlocking Business Growth Through Innovation

The business world is changing quickly for innovators and there is a growing and ever-present imperative to keep up. Business model transformations an…

innovation culture

Living in A Digital Transformation World

Digital transformation (DX) has been a hot topic in the innovation space for some time, but the term can be easily misunderstood as well. As we accele…

innovation frameworks

Innovation Principles, 1/7

Imagine a case where a company’s growth depends on an innovation involving complex cross-disciplinary technologies such as electro-mechanical hardwa…

innovation culture

Sustaining the Self-Disruption Journey

The adage “disrupt or be disrupted” may not necessarily always mean the same thing to the same companies. Even the original architects of disrupti…

innovation culture

Playing the Game of Disruption

At FEI, Angelina Carvajal, Strategy & Innovation Partner, Sr. Dir. (Optum Advisory), UnitedHealth Group, had a chance to share her thoughts on disrupt…

external partnerships

Powering Innovation’s Long-Term Play

Ishan Jaithwa, Manager, New Growth Areas, Cummins Inc., sat down with All Things Innovation’s Seth Adler at our studio at the FEI conference. Jaithw…

Innovation Resources
risk management

External Partnerships Fuel Innovation

As part of the continuing series of conversations at FEI with All Things Innovation’s Seth Adler, next on tap is Eric Agdeppa, R&D Director, Innovat…

product innovation

Design Thinking Faces the Pace of Change

Seth Adler of All Things Innovation recently caught up with Prapti Jha, T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Harvard University, at this year’s FEI co…

ideation

Opening the Doors of Innovation Perception

Seth Adler of All Things Innovation caught up with Cory Sorice, SVP and Chief Innovation Officer, Masonite International, during this year’s FEI con…

digital transformation

Supporting Data with Design Thinking

At FEI, All Things Innovation conducted a special roundtable, bringing cross industry, cross disciplinarians together to talk about transformation and…

digital transformation

Achieving Transformational Innovation

At FEI, All Things Innovation conducted a special roundtable, bringing cross industry, cross disciplinarians together to talk about transformation and…

chief financial officer

The Finance Factor in Innovation

The finance function in an organization often gets tabbed as a bottom line-oriented, conservative department that more often than not stifles innovati…

innovation team

Setting the Strategic Direction

A chief strategy officer (CSO) is increasingly becoming a more relevant element to a research and development team in an organization. An innovation t…

innovation talent

Managing the Marketing of Innovation

Even some of the best new innovations might fail if there’s no effective marketing behind the product or service. With an emphasis on cross-collabor…

objectives and key results

Playing Moneyball for the Win

In the popular baseball movie “Moneyball,” the character Peter Brand (played by Jonah Hill) highlights the “epic failure” of MLB leadership in managin…

innovation talent

Putting Together Your Innovation Team

As the community’s recent Innovation Spend & Trends Report indicated, innovation teams are not working in a bubble, or at least not as much as they…

6 D's framework

The Progress of Innovation

Technology is shaping our society, taking us in new directions and playing a key role in our lives every day. These forces can disrupt, or delight, co…

brand innovation

Leading with Product Innovation

At its core, in the consumer packaged goods world, an innovative product can make an impact in the marketplace and stand out with a focus on newness….

innovation strategy

Generating Innovation Through Ideation

Ideation is often confused with innovation, along with other related terms regarding the creative process, such as brainstorming or design thinking. W…

human resources

Managing Talent to Drive Innovation

With the economy producing mixed signals, and companies often in a state of flux, managing innovation talent has never been a more challenging and imp…

innovation culture

Balancing Innovation with Ambidexterity

Innovators have long been tasked with being a flexible part of an ambidextrous team, as part of an organizational cog that can easily pivot and manage…

sustainable technology

Defining Disruptive Innovation

Disruptive innovation is often a phrase used to make a splash in the business world. Some may debate that the label has been applied carelessly at tim…

sustaining innovation

Growing a Culture for Business Innovation

Whether it entails a large jump or a small step, the innovation pipeline for a business keeps it moving forward through a competitive landscape. Busin…

gaining true value

Gaining True Value While Moving Forward

The All Things Innovation community came together in this Gathering on Innovation Strategy to drive immediate lessons learned through the first half o…

data science

Diving Into Humanity-Centric Innovation

With the continued emergence and evolving development of artificial intelligence, there rises a question of how humans and AI can work together more e…

innovation team

Tapping Into the Innovation Talent Pipeline

In the last few years, the pandemic and a range of other economic factors have influenced the talent recruitment, development and retention practices…

innovation culture

Ignite a Culture of Innovation

From the successes to the failures, from the breakthroughs to the breaking points, the innovation community knows all too well that fostering a cultur…

business innovation

Innovation During A Downturn

Whether you believe the USA is headed toward or already in a recession, there are signs of a slowing or reversal of economic activity. Of the 15 metri…

ideation

Striving for Successful Innovation

In the quest for innovation, there is often a fine line between success and failure. The road to success is not always clear, easy or convenient. Howe…

diversity

Innovation Diversity

Black, Indigenous and People of Color have always been leaders in innovation and it’s time for us to put that at the forefront. DEI, or Diversity Eq…

fostering innovation

Fostering Innovation

When you start to talk that way and lead that way, people do feel more psychologically safe to support change and support innovation that’s happenin…

innovation leadership

Breakthrough Innovation

While the rest of the industry relies on iterative change, Alex Moyes explains the breakthrough innovation happening at Dominion Energy. “So Dominio…

virtual reality

Innovation Reality

When working remotely, the main challenge is bringing people into an office when they live across the country or around the world. The AES Corporation…

innovation leadership

Control The Sails

Although the world was affected heavily with change in the last few years, not much in the business world has changed as far as topics and issues go….

innovation leadership

Innovation Culture

Innovation starts with the employees of an organization. As we know, the people that work for a business are some of its greatest assets. In today’s…

ideation

Interaction Innovation

We are at a time in history of incredible change and technological innovations, such as the rise of machine intelligence, and companies who keep doing…

technology

Humanity-Centric Innovation

Humanity-centric innovation is the idea of solving the biggest problems facing humanity in an economically viable way. Pete Dulcamara, Chief Scientist…

innovation culture

Measurable Innovation

Each company has their own KPIs that are important to their specific business in place to progress and be successful. Are people at the forefront of i…

innovation culture

Certain Uncertainty

Life is uncertain in every way. It’s always interesting to meet new people and try new things. On the other hand, attackers may sometimes appear out o…

innovation culture

Rolling Innovation

If you’ve done it once, you can do it again. Make sure to keep doing it, it’s rolling innovation. Amber Case sits down with us to discuss how impo…

advancing innovation

Strategic Innovation

Any new concept or technological advancement will continue to change and advance. Landlines were commonplace before smartphones. Remember those? What…

transformation

Innovation Intelligence

It seems that innovation is one of the biggest buzzwords in business now. To sustain growth and be competitive in the marketplace, companies in every…

transformation

Innovation As Constant Change

The key strategy to a successful business is to know when they are being innovative or are just transforming their status quo according to market tren…

innovation strategy

Innovation versus Transformation

Many people think digital transformation and innovation are one in the same, but according to Hatrick, while they are closely related, there is a diff…