Skip to content

The Blockbuster Blunder: A Cautionary Tale of Strategy Gone Wrong

Many of us have fond memories of Friday nights at Blockbuster, perusing shelves of VHS tapes and DVDs, debating whether to rent “Jurassic Park” for the 17th time or take a chance on that obscure indie film. But nostalgia couldn’t save this once-dominant brand from becoming the punchline of business school case studies. Blockbuster’s downfall offers fundamental lessons about the importance of sound strategy and the role data science can play in shaping it—or in Blockbuster’s case, how ignoring data can lead to a business horror story scarier than anything in their “Late Night” section.

The Meeting: A Desperate Grab for Relevance

Picture this: There I was, the head of analytics at a major ad agency, sitting across from Blockbuster’s C-suite in their Texas headquarters. The tension was thicker than the plot of a Christopher Nolan movie. The CEO, looking like he’d just watched his company’s stock price perform a Swan Lake death scene, outlined their strategy to turn the struggling company around, which included such straw-grasps as:

  1. Transform rental locations into retail stores selling merchandise.
  2. Branch out into selling tickets for live events.

As he spoke, I felt a growing sense of unease, like I was watching a car crash in slow motion. This wasn’t a strategy; it was a Hail Mary pass thrown by a quarterback who wasn’t sure which end zone was his.

The Problem: Misguided Desperation

Now, don’t get me wrong. Blockbuster’s team wasn’t stupid. They were desperate, and desperation can make even the smartest cookies crumble. Their core business was eroding faster than a sandcastle at high tide, thanks to Netflix’s DVD-by-mail business and the rise of streaming services. In their panic, they had broken the glass to grasp desperately at the emergency lever, concocting a strategy that was more wishful thinking than coherent plan.

Their approach was problematic for several reasons. First, Blockbuster had about as much experience in merchandising or event ticket sales as I do in neurosurgery. They were ignoring the real threat—the shift to digital streaming—like an ostrich with its head in the sand, if the sand was a pile of unsold DVDs. Transforming their stores would drain resources faster than a leaky bucket, leaving nothing for potential digital innovations. And let’s not forget they were trying to muscle into markets already crowded with specialized competitors—they were bringing a plastic knife to a gunfight.

The potential consequences were severe: wasted resources, confused customers, and a continued decline in their core business. Ultimately, this misguided strategy accelerated Blockbuster’s demise rather than saving it. It was like trying to bail out the Titanic with a teaspoon—energetic, but ultimately futile.

The Broader Context: A Common Pitfall

Blockbuster’s misstep isn’t unique in the business world. It’s like there’s a support group out there: “Welcome to Strategic Blunders Anonymous.” Consider an old client of mine, Kodak, who invented the digital camera but clung to their film business like it was the last life raft on the Titanic. They filed for bankruptcy in 2012, proving that even being first doesn’t matter if you’re running in the wrong direction. Then there’s Borders Books, who expanded aggressively into music and video, neglecting the growing e-book market. They ended up liquidating in 2011, a cautionary tale of what happens when you bring a bookshelf to an e-reader fight.

These cases share a common thread: wishful thinking masquerading as strategy, like a kid wearing their parent’s clothes and pretending to be an adult. It’s cute when a five-year-old does it, less so when it’s a billion-dollar corporation.

What is Strategy, Really?

So, if we know what strategy isn’t (a wish list, a Hail Mary, or a series of random tactics thrown at the wall to see what sticks), what is it? Strategy isn’t just a fancy word to make the C-suite feel important. It’s a cohesive framework for achieving a specific, well-defined goal. Think of it as the GPS for your business road trip—without it, you’re just driving around aimlessly, burning fuel and getting nowhere.

Richard Rumelt, in his book Good Strategy, Bad Strategy, outlines three key elements of a solid strategy. First, you need a clear diagnosis—understanding the challenges and opportunities facing your organization. It’s like going to the doctor; you can’t treat the disease if you don’t know what it is.

Next comes the guiding policy, a general approach to overcoming the challenges identified in your diagnosis. This is your North Star, providing a consistent direction for decision-making throughout the organization. Without it, your company is like a ship without a rudder, at the mercy of whatever wind happens to be blowing that day.

Finally, you need coherent actions—a set of coordinated steps designed to carry out your guiding policy. Without this, even the best policy remains just a good idea, like that gym membership you bought in January and haven’t used since February.

The Role of Data Science in Strategy

This is where data scientists come in, armed with our algorithms and our slightly unhealthy obsession with spreadsheets. We’re not just number crunchers or the folks you call when your computer acts up (that’s IT, for the last time!). We can play an essential role in developing and executing strategy.

We’re the Ghostbusters of the business world, but instead of proton packs, we carry powerful forecasting models to project future trends. We’re the reality check when the sales team starts spouting off about hockey stick growth projections that look more like a giraffe’s neck. We can set realistic KPIs and develop SMART goals, ensuring your objectives are more achievable than time travel and more specific than “do better.”

But wait, there’s more! We’re also your guides through the maze of data-driven decision making. We can provide insights from complex data sets that are clearer than a bell and more actionable than a triple espresso on a Monday morning. And when it comes to preparing for the future, our scenario planning capabilities make us the corporate world’s equivalent of fortune tellers, minus the crystal ball and questionable fashion choices.

Learning from Blockbuster’s Mistakes

What can we learn from Blockbuster’s ill-fated attempt to blockbust itself? First, stay true to your core. Blockbuster trying to sell t-shirts and concert tickets was like McDonald’s deciding to pivot into haute cuisine—stick to what you know. They could have leveraged their brand recognition to move into digital streaming, but instead, they zigged when they should have zagged.

Second, don’t ignore the elephant in the room, especially when that elephant is stomping all over your business model. Blockbuster should have tackled the shift to digital head-on, instead of pretending it was just a passing fad like pet rocks or low-rise jeans.

Third, use your data wisely. Blockbuster probably had more data than they knew what to do with, showing the rise of streaming. But having data and using it effectively are two different things—like owning a treadmill and actually using it to exercise instead of as an expensive clothes hanger.

Fourth, think long-term. Avoid short-term fixes for long-term problems. It’s like putting a band-aid on a broken leg. It might make you feel better for a moment, but it’s not solving the real issue. And come to think of it, it probably wouldn’t even make you feel better for that moment.

Finally, be realistic. Optimism is great, but too much of it is like too much sugar—it’ll give you a quick high before the crash. Blockbuster’s plan to suddenly dominate new markets was about as realistic as my plan to win an Olympic gold medal in figure skating (I can’t even ice skate).

The Power of Good Strategy

In the end, Blockbuster’s story serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of sound strategy in business. As data scientists, we have the tools and skills to contribute meaningfully to strategic discussions, grounding them in data-driven insights and realistic projections. We’re the voice of reason in a world that sometimes seems to have lost its mind, the ones who can tell you that no, the emperor really isn’t wearing any clothes. And we’re the digital tailor that can take the measurements to sew him some.

But remember, while data is super-extra-duper important, it’s not everything. Good strategy also requires creativity, industry knowledge, and the courage to make tough decisions. It’s about combining the art of business with the science of data, like an awkward make-out session between intuition and cold, hard facts.

So let’s learn from Blockbuster’s mistakes. Let’s harness the power of data, craft strategies that stand the test of time, and maybe, just maybe, avoid becoming the next cautionary tale in the business strategy hall of fame. After all, in the game of business, you either win and become a case study, or you still become a case study, just a much more depressing one.

Your move, C-suite.

For more columns from Michael Bagalman’s Data Science for Decision Makers series, click here.

Contributor

  • Michael Bagalman brings a wealth of experience applying data science and analytics to solve complex business challenges. As VP of Business Intelligence and Data Science at STARZ, he leads a team leveraging data to inform decision-making across the organization. Bagalman has previously built and managed analytics teams at Sony Pictures, AT&T, Publicis, and Deutsch. He is passionate about translating cutting-edge techniques into tangible insights executives can act on. Bagalman holds degrees from Harvard and Princeton and teaches marketing analytics at the university level. Through his monthly column, he aims to demystify important data science concepts for leaders seeking to harness analytics to drive growth.

    View all posts
 
 

Related Content

Office building filled with dark and lit windows at night.
social innovation

Defining Business Innovation

Business innovation refers to the process of introducing new ideas, products, services, or processes into a business to create value and gain a compet…

A digital-like button that says "Start."
data science

Leveraging Insights to Reach Innovation

With the production of insights comes learning about your marketplace and consumer, actionable findings, and agile decision-making—all of which can…

A big road sign that says The Future is Now.
data science

Inspiring The Future of Innovation

TMRE 2024, recently held in Orlando, gathered the market research community for a broad range of conversations and discussions from all manner of insi…

A welder with helmet welding steel, with smoke, heat and sparks.
data science

Leading Innovation Through Change

A resilient insights community came together at Universal’s Loews Sapphire Falls Resort in Orlando, FL, this past December for TMRE 2024. The market…

A gold pocket watch half buried in the sand.
data science

Top Innovation Themes from 2024

As we close out our review of 2024, we wanted to examine the top innovation themes of the year, based on our blogs, research reports and events. To do…

Cooking in a wok on a steamy and fiery stove.
artificial intelligence

Cooking Up Innovation: A Review of Q3 2024

During the third quarter of 2024, All Things Innovation was busy preparing coverage for the recently concluded FEI 2024 conference in June and present…

artificial intelligence

Sparking Innovation: A Review of Q2 2024

During the second quarter of 2024, All Things Innovation was busy preparing for the upcoming FEI 2024 conference in June and presenting a broad range…

A matrix-like image of code going down the information/data highway.
ecosystems

Innovation Community Resources on Analytics

As we continue to look back and explore the educational sessions at FEI 2024, All Things Innovation brings you an extra edition featuring additional r…

A graphic of a light bulb with a large number of machine gears (in place of the actual bulb).
innovation culture

Innovation Community Resources on Process

All Things Innovation brings you a bonus edition featuring additional research, insights and resources centered on FEI 2024’s Process track. The tra…

A digital hand and a human hand touching through a futuristic background.
machine learning

The Future of AI: A Roundtable Perspective

A key session at FEI 2024 earlier in the year was the GenAI Use Case Roundtables, where the entire show delegation shared opportunities and concerns w…

Big pile of light bulbs with one lit up.
data science

Unlocking the Potential of Data Innovation

With FEI 2024’s focus on AI, human capabilities, and the data-innovation journey, among other topics, All Things Innovation had a chance to discuss…

Young woman (Gen Z) having her picture taken with a smartphone at outdoor cafe.
influencers

Gen Z on Corporate Innovation

Meet the generation disrupting the way we innovate: Generation Z. As Gen Z enters the workforce and embraces entrepreneurship, there’s a growing need…

A large spinning wind turbine.
sustainable innovation

Energizing Sustainable Solutions

All Things Innovation spent some time at FEI 2024 with Serene Hamsho, President of American Offshore Wind Academy, which provides professional trainin…

Colorful USB plugs moving up like a chart from left to right.
innovation talent

Plugging into AI & ML Adoption

In the rapidly evolving landscape of consumer-packaged goods (CPG), the integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) is no lo…

A diamond and its facets.
digital transformation

Finding the Value of Innovation

Gail Martino, VP Partnerships, 387Labs, was on hand at FEI 2024 as a moderator for the Brunch with the Bots presentation on the final day of the confe…

A spiral seashell.
agile principles

Supporting Agile Innovation

Often, when we think about large corporations, rapid innovation and agile development may not be the first principles that come to mind. Large corpora…

Variety of bubbles floating on a black background.
startups

Adopting an Innovation Ecosystem

From small startups to large corporations, sometimes the process of innovation includes the need for an innovation ecosystem. Just how that is defined…

Three architects looking over blueprints at building site.
analytics

Building the Right Data & Insights Team

You’ve heard it before: Data is the new oil. Just as crude oil needs refining to become valuable, data must be processed to unlock its potential. Ente…

Closeup of the side of a sleek red racecar.
innovation mindset

Data-Driven: A Winning Formula for Innovation

Maximiliano Just, Vice President, Data Governance and Shared Platforms at a Fortune 100 company, was a speaker at the recent FEI 2024 conference. As i…

The closeup of a jet engine.
fail fast

Creating a Culture of Experimentation

Many in the community feel that fostering a culture of innovation is paramount. A key to this is building a culture of experimentation. This stems fro…

An Olympic swimmer in the pool racing.
innovation strategy

Is Your Company Innovation Ready?

The term innovation readiness is often used to refer to an organization’s ability to develop and launch new products, services or ideas. Some may poin…

A sphere in space, with data points of light
innovation team

Innovation in Action: Trends from FEI 2024

This past June, the vibrant city of Boston, known for its trailblazing spirit, became the epicenter of innovation as it hosted the Front End of Innova…

Crumpled paper on top of idea/innovation sketch pad with drawing of light bulb.
innovation mindset

FEI 2024 Report: The Future of Innovation

A successful three-day event marked Front End of Innovation (FEI) 2024 in Boston, held June 10 to 12 at the Omni Hotel at the Seaport. A reenergized a…

Lifting a hand weight at the gym/fitness theme.
innovation culture

Harnessing the Power of Consumer Insights

Innovation doesn’t happen in a silo, and a great product or idea can only go so far on its own. Tapping into the pulse of your consumer is key to ta…

A white empty picture frame leaning on a white brick wall.
innovation systems

Selecting an Innovation Framework

The science of innovation, especially as seen through frameworks, is an important aspect of the operational process. With innovation a sometimes spraw…

A hand holding a glowing green globe.
sustainable innovation

A Call for Sustainable Development

An MIT environmental engineering undergraduate from Jamaica, Runako Gentles uses his personal story to advocate for sustainable development to be inte…

Futuristic city at night with data points of light rising from the bottom.
partnerships

Mapping Out the Data-Innovation Journey

This year, in our latest Innovation Perspectives Report, the editors of All Things Innovation brought together a cross-section of innovation, insights…

Bulletin board with post it notes. One in center says Make Things Happen.
productivity

Managing Productive Innovation

Conservatively, I estimate that I’ve attended 20,000-plus meetings throughout my career. I’ll admit, many of them should have been replaced with email…

An accelerating speedometer.
data science

Accelerating a Data-Driven Approach

If we accept that data lies at the heart of marketing and business decision-making, a data-driven approach must be paramount in today’s environment….

a surface of black cubes rising from floor, varying heights, one stands out in yellow above the rest.
data science

Leveraging AI in B2B Respondent Insights

In the B2B marketing landscape, artificial intelligence has shown great potential. It is becoming an essential and advantageous tool, a tool which no…

coin operated binoculars and open blue sky
artificial intelligence

The Road to FEI24: Analytics for Innovation

Anu Sundaram, Vice President, Business Analytics, Rue Gilt Groupe, is planning an interactive analytics session for FEI 2024, taking place this June….

laboratory beaker with dropper
new product development

Transform New Product Development with AI

While AI is certainly touted as being able to create rapid data-driven insights, there are advantages in the new product development process that can…

honey jars with dripping honey
business model innovation

Capturing Value with Business Model Innovation

While product and service innovation are integral in today’s competitive business environment, one shouldn’t overlook creating value through busin…

explorer in a cave
user experience

Applying AI to Anthropological Research

Agile research and methodologies are of primary importance to the innovation discipline, as they promote a more versatile, rapid, adaptive approach to…

Shopper in a grocery store.
innovation technology

8 Risks If You Don’t Have an AI Strategy

In the fast-paced world of Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG), where product life cycles are short and consumer trends shift with lightning speed, stay…

prompt engineering
machine learning

Positioning the Role of Prompt Engineering

Prompt engineering is one of the latest buzzwords when it comes to artificial intelligence, but what is this evolving and complex job function? Some m…

automation

Powering AI-Driven Innovation

The advancements in artificial intelligence have rapidly impacted and transformed the business world around us. For insights and innovation, it has in…

data management

Finding Best Practices for Data Management

Data management is critical in today’s innovation and overall business environment. This ensures that data is collected, cleansed, analyzed and stor…

future of work

Gaining an Innovation Edge with Automation

With the focus on how artificial intelligence, as well as digital transformation efforts, can help streamline operations, it’s worth another look at…

human-technology interaction

Advancing Universal Interaction

Artificial intelligence, specifically generative AI, has the potential to be a great equalizing disruptive technology of our time. While we are still…

artificial intelligence

How AI is Redefining Business Strategy

Over the last year, AI went from being the next big thing to being the Big Thing. In particular, Large Language Models (LLMs) from companies like Open…

innovation culture

Winning the Innovation Strategy Game

We know that having a creative mindset can fuel innovation, and that fostering a culture of innovation is also important to get the job done. Yet ther…

innovation culture

Taking Next Steps with Innovation Talent

As we head into the new year, taking the next steps with innovation talent remains an important question to explore. With the competitive landscape in…

disruptive innovation

Shaping the Future with Disruptive Technology

As we head into 2024, innovation of all types, most especially in technology, will continue to disrupt, transform and impact our lives, from the workp…

innovation frameworks

Innovation Principles, 3/7

The main premise behind an integrated end-to-end continuum of innovation and new product development is that a holistic understanding of sequential de…

generative AI

The Impact of AI on Innovation

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is having a profound impact and influence on a broad range of industries. From healthcare to publishing to industrial fie…

measuring innovation

Measuring Innovation Performance

Innovation can be a key component to drive a company’s success and performance, in both short-term and long-term initiatives. Yet many executives gr…

technology

Living in A Digital Transformation World

Digital transformation (DX) has been a hot topic in the innovation space for some time, but the term can be easily misunderstood as well. As we accele…

innovation frameworks

Innovation Principles, 1/7

Imagine a case where a company’s growth depends on an innovation involving complex cross-disciplinary technologies such as electro-mechanical hardwa…

disruptive innovation

Sustaining the Self-Disruption Journey

The adage “disrupt or be disrupted” may not necessarily always mean the same thing to the same companies. Even the original architects of disrupti…

disruptive innovation

Playing the Game of Disruption

At FEI, Angelina Carvajal, Strategy & Innovation Partner, Sr. Dir. (Optum Advisory), UnitedHealth Group, had a chance to share her thoughts on disrupt…

product innovation

People Remain the Critical Link to Innovation

All Things Innovation’s Seth Adler got a chance to sit down with Milan Ivosevic, VP R&D, CooperSurgical, at this year’s FEI conference. Ivosevic a…

innovation leadership

The Finance Factor in Innovation

The finance function in an organization often gets tabbed as a bottom line-oriented, conservative department that more often than not stifles innovati…

innovation leadership

Setting the Strategic Direction

A chief strategy officer (CSO) is increasingly becoming a more relevant element to a research and development team in an organization. An innovation t…

agility

Playing Moneyball for the Win

In the popular baseball movie “Moneyball,” the character Peter Brand (played by Jonah Hill) highlights the “epic failure” of MLB leadership in managin…

digital transformation

The Progress of Innovation

Technology is shaping our society, taking us in new directions and playing a key role in our lives every day. These forces can disrupt, or delight, co…

scalable innovation

Sizing Up Your Innovation’s Impact

If your company has successfully developed an innovative product or service, you might be at the stage of the process known as scalability. Perhaps yo…

sustainable technology

Defining Disruptive Innovation

Disruptive innovation is often a phrase used to make a splash in the business world. Some may debate that the label has been applied carelessly at tim…

humanity-centric innovation

Diving Into Humanity-Centric Innovation

With the continued emergence and evolving development of artificial intelligence, there rises a question of how humans and AI can work together more e…

advancing innovation

15 Second Workday

This morning I generated 40 new product ideas with concepts and ad copy to accompany each.  It took 15 seconds. This is just a small fraction of what…

innovation leadership

Breakthrough Innovation

While the rest of the industry relies on iterative change, Alex Moyes explains the breakthrough innovation happening at Dominion Energy. “So Dominio…

innovation frameworks

Innovation Ecosystems

Innovation is a journey, it’s a continuum of experiences, an act of exploration. The orchestration of ecosystems is more and more important in consi…

innovation leadership

Control The Sails

Although the world was affected heavily with change in the last few years, not much in the business world has changed as far as topics and issues go….

innovation talent

Innovation Culture

Innovation starts with the employees of an organization. As we know, the people that work for a business are some of its greatest assets. In today’s…

data and analytics

Measurable Innovation

Each company has their own KPIs that are important to their specific business in place to progress and be successful. Are people at the forefront of i…

innovation culture

Certain Uncertainty

Life is uncertain in every way. It’s always interesting to meet new people and try new things. On the other hand, attackers may sometimes appear out o…